![]() |
>As money pours into the state treasury, some legislators are going crazy with ideas for spending it all. A proposal making the rounds in Juneau calls for spending $21 billion (yes, billion) on renewable and alternative energy.
That's a breathtakingly outrageous and irresponsible amount of money. The Legislature already passed a bill this year to spend $250 million on renewable energy projects like hydro-power and wind power over the next five years.But Rep. John Harris thinks we need to spend 80 times as much. He drafted the bill for a $21 billion, five-year energy project fund. The money isn't just for renewable energy; it's for "alternative" energy projects as well. That's to make room for an unproven Fairbanks project that uses coal -- not a renewable resource -- to produce liquid fuels.Fairbanks North Star Borough Mayor Jim Whitaker helped Harris develop the $21 billion bill, which so far is just in draft form. "That number was chosen because that is a number that is meaningful," said Whitaker. It will give substance to a statewide energy plan the administration is working on, he said.Maybe the state will need to put more than currently planned into renewable energy, but $21 billion? That's enough money to fund the state's entire K-12 education system for two decades. Educating children is a constitutionally mandated function of state government. Supplying cheaper energy is not.There's simply no need to change the renewable energy fund to an "alternative" energy fund that encompasses projects using coal, a dirty-burning fossil fuel. Many ideas for getting affordable fuels to Alaskans are on the table. We're studying a Susitna dam, an in-state natural gas pipeline, wind power, geothermal. Exploring them all could burn up a lot of state money.There's a TV show called "House" where a doctor named House is given the most difficult cases to diagnose. Every episode, House makes one wrong diagnosis after another, subjecting patients to extreme treatments that send them to the brink of death, before he finally arrives at the right answer. Speaker Harris is playing Dr. House. He's ready to throw $21 billion at Alaskans' energy problems, with no idea which ones might actually work. Even with $140-a-barrel oil, Alaska can't afford that kind of gamble. What Speaker Harris wants to do is not an energy policy -- it's a political move that will empty the state's pocketbook. BOTTOM LINE: Keep the focus on renewable projects, and keep the dollars committed to a reasonable amount.