Judge OKs Murkowski say in Miller lawsuit

Published: December 2, 2010 

Scott Kendall, an attorney for Lisa Murkowski's U.S. Senate campaign, speaks to Ketchikan Superior Court Judge William Carey via teleconference in Juneau on Wednesday, Dec. 1, 2010. On Thursday, Carey ruled that Murkowski could have a say in a legal challenge involving Alaska's Senate ballots.

MICHAEL PENN / THE JUNEAU EMPIRE VIA THE ASSOCIATED PRESS

INTERVENING: She could fight for 2,016 ballots the state didn't count for her.

A state court judge on Thursday agreed to let Sen. Lisa Murkowski have a say in a legal challenge to Alaska's U.S. Senate race.

Attorneys for Murkowski argued that she should be allowed to intervene in the lawsuit that her Republican rival, Joe Miller, brought against the state over the manner in which it conducted the election.

Miller contends the state did not follow the law, notably in its decision to use discretion in tallying write-in votes for Murkowski.

Attorney Scott Kendall said in court Wednesday that Murkowski should be entitled to protect her "victory" and have a say in the proceedings. Judge William Carey agreed to let her into the case.

Unofficial results from the Nov. 2 election showed Murkowski with a lead and she has declared victory. Her attorneys maintained her interests wouldn't be adequately represented by the state in the case, as Miller's attorneys argued they would be.

Murkowski ran as a write-in candidate after losing her primary to Miller. Results showed Murkowski with 101,088 votes, compared to Miller's 90,760. Excluding ballots challenged by Miller observers over a week of hand-counting ballots, she held a 2,169-vote lead.

Kendall said Murkowski was at odds with the state over its decision not to count another 2,016 ballots for her.

Many of those did not have the ballot ovals filled in but had her name written in. Others, according to attorney Scott Kendall, had "Lisa M." written in, or various misspellings.

He said those ballots represent a significant chunk of the more than 258,000 total ballots cast.

The judge's decision means Murkowski would be able to fight to have those ballots included, if things got to that point.

Also Thursday, the Alaska Federation of Natives sought a voice in the case, either as an intervener or in support of the state. A similar effort was denied in an earlier federal court case.

The state's largest Alaska Native group, which endorsed Murkowski, claims Alaska Natives would be disenfranchised if their ballots for Murkowski were tossed because they didn't have perfect spelling.

Order Reprint Back to Top

Top Jobs

View All Top Jobs

Find a Home

$877,000 Anchorage
4 bed, 4 full bath. Enjoy the privacy of this gated culdesac...

Find a Car

Search New Cars
Ads by Yahoo!