Judge to decide on Miller's Senate vote challenge by Friday

SENATE SEAT: Parnell orders research into interim appointment.

December 8, 2010 

JUNEAU -- An Alaska judge will decide by Friday a case that will determine the fate of Republican Joe Miller's challenge to how write-in ballots were counted in the U.S. Senate race.

Judge William Carey will determine whether to grant the state's request to dismiss Miller's lawsuit or grant Miller's request to strictly enforce election law. He heard arguments for almost two hours Wednesday.

A decision for Miller could result in thousands of challenged write-in ballots for Sen. Lisa Murkowski being reviewed and lead to a recount, a prospect attorneys for Murkowski argue could leave Alaska with just one senator when the new Congress is sworn in.

Murkowski ran a write-in campaign after losing the primary to Miller. The unofficial tally, after a weeklong hand count observed by the Murkowski and Miller camps, showed her ahead by 10,328 votes, or 2,169 when excluding votes challenged by Miller. The state argues the math isn't in Miller's favor regardless of what the judge decides.

But Miller has raised concerns about voting irregularities that he says put enough ballots into question to possibly sway the election. His claims include similar-looking signatures on ballots, precincts where voters were allowed to cast ballots without providing identification, and newly raised allegations about felon sex offenders being allowed to vote.

While the similar-appearing signatures could be due to voters requesting and receiving legally acceptable help in casting ballots, Miller's attorney, Michael Morley, told Carey the concerns are credible and substantial enough that a reasonable person would find them "disturbing."

Any decision is expected to be appealed to the state Supreme Court.

Miller, who attended Wednesday's hearing, has not conceded the election. He has maintained his challenge is less about win-or-lose for him than it is about principle and ensuring Alaskans got a fair election. The state asserts that happened.

Assistant Attorney General Joanne Grace told Carey the case "is really a poster child for why the Legislature requires extremely high standards for post-election lawsuits."

She said Miller has not met the burden for showing there was any voting fraud or corruption. She also disputed his claim that the state failed to promulgate rules for administering the write-in count, saying special rule making wasn't necessary, given the write-in review called for a "common-sense interpretation" of the law.

The state asked Carey to rule by today, to allow time for any appeals and to return to the federal court that had put a stay on certification pending resolution of the issues raised by Miller. Carey said he'd try but that it may be Friday before he rules.

Gov. Sean Parnell said Wednesday he is willing to explore "all legal avenues" to ensure Alaska is fully represented in the Senate if the case drags on, including looking at whether an interim appointment may be needed. He said he has asked the Department of Law to research the matter. Parnell backed Miller during the general election but declined to say whether he thinks Miller should concede.

Anchorage Daily News is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Commenting FAQs | Terms of Service

Top Jobs

View All

Find a Home

$18,169,000 Anchorage
. A confidentiality agreement is required to get any information...

Find a Car

Search New Cars