No punitive damages in jury award for man hit by cop

casey.grove@adn.comJune 18, 2013 

An Anchorage jury has awarded $375,000 to a man injured when a distracted police officer's patrol car hit his pickup in 2010.

While the jury ruled Friday in favor of the plaintiff, Melvin Rush, the jurors did not award the $2.5 million in punitive damages sought by Rush.

Rush's lawyer, Jim Valcarce, said 11-year veteran Officer Michael Wisel was looking at his in-car computer at the time of the wreck. Wisel's supervisors failed to deal with his pattern of poor driving, which included other incidents involving distracted driving, Valcarce said.

"My client is pleased with the result, but we all wish the jury would've sent a message of punishment," Valcarce said. "Because that's what punitive damages do. You punish someone and make sure it never happens again."

Valcarce called Wisel's driving "outrageous reckless conduct." The case exposed the fact that Anchorage police officers who commit traffic offenses, while not responding to an emergency, are never ticketed, Valcarce said.

"They do nothing to them. Not a slap on the hand. Nothing," he said. "That's why that was so important. Because of that mind set of, 'I can do whatever I want and nothing's going to happen to me.'"

According to a police spokeswoman, officers face consequences for poor driving that are sometimes more serious than a traffic citation. In the case of his collision with Rush, Wisel received a verbal reprimand, Valcarce said.

The city paid Rush's medical bills and the cost to repair his pickup, Valcarce said. But city attorneys offered Rush only $27,500 for his past and future suffering, the lawyer said. Rush never wanted to go to court, Valcarce said.

"He's embarrassed by the publicity," Valcarce said. "His family thanks God every day he's just alive."

A city attorney handling the case did not immediately return calls seeking comment on the jury award. The city's position at trial was that Wisel was at fault in the wreck but that Rush was not owed punitive damages.

Reach Casey Grove at or 257-4589.



Anchorage Daily News is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Commenting FAQs | Terms of Service