To pass or to run, that is the question

jpeters@adn.comSeptember 26, 2013 

— When South and Service meet on the gridiron, football philosophers get an opportunity to debate.

Last weekend's meeting between the Cook Inlet Conference's top two teams was more than just two rivals battling for first place. It was a clash of the running game against the passing game.

The passing team won this time.

Service wrested the top spot in the CIC standings from South in a 37-36 shootout that featured 59 pass attempts from Service quarterback C.J. Toomer and 50 rushing attempts from the defending state champion Wolverines.

"I believe the running game is gonna beat the passing game, and I still believe it," said South coach John Lewis. "We proved it last year. We almost proved it here."

South (4-2) defeated Service (5-1) in last season's state title game, 28-19, avenging a 37-23 loss to the Cougars in the 2011 state title game. Last weekend's meeting might have gone the Wolverines' way if it weren't for losing the turnover battle, 5-3, missing two extra points and missing a short field-goal attempt with less than two minutes to play.

In a game that went down to the wire, the teams couldn't have utilized more contrasting offensive strategies. The Cougars attempted 40 passes in the first half on their way to more than tripling South's 14 pass attempts and gaining 435 yards through the air to South's 126.

The Wolverines did the bulk of their damage on the ground, gaining 278 rushing yards to Service's 65, nearly doubling Service's 27 carries.

"I'm a defensive guy, but basically it is fun," Service coach Kevin Kern said of the offensive show. "C. J.'s a great guy and a great quarterback, and he does a great job. If we stick to our game plan, this is the kind of victory we get."

Toomer's 1,729 passing yards this season more than doubles the yardage of any other CIC quarterback and his 21 touchdowns are triple that of the nearest competitor. With two regular-season games remaining and a postseason to get through, Toomer has a shot at breaking the unofficial single-season passing record of 2,559 yards set by West's Conor Feckley in 2011. With or without Toomer, Service would likely still adhere to a gunslinger mentality, Kern said.

"I got about 10 receivers that do a great job," said Kern. "We got another quarterback who can throw. We got two backups that can throw."

Lewis has coached football at South since the school opened in the fall of 2004, leading the Wolverines to state titles in 2006 and 2012. Each year, Lewis uses a multitude of running backs to pound the rock and wear out defenses. Its rough nature is the reason he believes the running game is the tried and true method for success against any opponent.

South's defense is geared to stopping the run, which has worked wonders against the rest of the CIC. The Wolverines surrendered just 13 points in the four CIC games prior to meeting Service. A new defensive scheme was in place to take on the Cougars and it worked well enough in the early going to help South build a 21-2 lead. Things started going awry when two of South's top defensive backs got hurt, Lewis said.

The injuries forced South into a zone defense that Toomer picked apart by more easily targeting specific defenders and areas, Lewis said. Toomer fired four touchdown passes after the South injuries, cutting that 21-2 South lead to 21-16 with a pair of scores before halftime and throwing two more touchdowns in the second half.

"He (Toomer) didn't throw but one ball in my zone the whole game," said South safety and quarterback Alec Valdez. "He didn't even put it where there was a chance I could get a pick. That's something I need to learn from (as a quarterback)."

Valdez proved a capable passer with touchdown passes of 26 and 28 yards, but also threw three interceptions. A runner first, Valdez showed off blazing speed on a 59-yard touchdown run on the opening play of the second half, giving South a 27-16 lead.

"The first play of the second half, everybody connected and everything was perfect and everything started to flow," Valdez said. "Honestly, more of the time, I'm asking the coach to run the ball. I played running back since second grade and that's my thing."

With Service and South holding the top two spots in the CIC, they've each clinched playoff berths. Depending on seeding, there is a chance the teams could meet in the large-school state title game for the third straight season, pitting pass against run on the state's biggest stage.

"It's a game of patience," Lewis said. "These guys, they make big plays, so you just gotta be patient."

Reach Jeremy Peters at or 257-4335.

High School football

  Conference Overall
  W L PF PA Pct. W L PF PA Pct.
Service 4 1 200 110 .800 5 1 252 131 .833 South 4 1 198 50 .800 4 2 198 69 .666 West 4 1 115 71 .800 4 2 129 95 .666 Chugiak 3 2 85 123 .600 4 2 102 129 .666 Dimond 3 2 95 59 .600 3 3 101 83 .500 Eagle River 1 4 107 184 .200 1 5 115 224 .167 Bartlett 1 4 50 106 .200 1 5 65 127 .167 East 0 5 37 184 .000 0 6 37 216 .000
Week 7 Schedule
Wednesday's Result

Monroe 54, Vosnesenka 0

Friday's Games

Barrow at Seward, 5 p.m.
Chugiak vs. East, AFS, 7 p.m.
South at Dimond, 7 p.m.
West Valley at North Pole, 7 p.m.
Colony at Palmer, 7 p.m.
Juneau at Wasilla, 7 p.m.

Saturday's Games

Nikiski at Eielson, 1 p.m.
Service vs. West, AFS, 2 p.m.
Skyview at Soldotna, 2 p.m.
Houston at Kodiak, 2 p.m.
Lathrop at Homer, 3 p.m.
Eagle River vs. Bartlett, AFS, 7 p.m.
Ketchikan at Thunder Mtn., 7 p.m.

CIC Leaders Through Week 6


  Att Yds TDs Avg
Gabe Mingledorff, Chugiak 83 587 4 7.1 Lui Faamasino, West 85 519 6 6.1 J.J. Tanuvasa, Dimond 57 365 3 6.4 Justice Augafa, South 50 364 5 7.3 Ed Hall, Eagle River 98 362 6 3.7

  Comp Att Yds TDs Int
C.J. Toomer, Service 108 211 1,729 21 3 Jeremiah Maga, Dimond 50 97 680 7 9 Tyrone Davis, West 39 77 574 7 3 Peter Kott, Eagle River 31 89 537 3 6 Zyrelle Jones, Bartlett 39 94 415 4 5

  Rec Yds TDs Avg
Nashon Fromm, Service 28 492 5 17.6 Armend Aliju, Service 22 304 5 13.8 Leroy Elliot, West 21 443 6 21.1 Marquise Rayford, West 20 237 1 11.9 Marquez Buster, Dimond 20 266 3 13.3
* Statistics are unofficial, and based on game coverage by the ADN and other newspapers, and information provided by varsity coaching staffs. There is no official stat-keeping body for Alaska football.


Anchorage Daily News is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Commenting FAQs | Terms of Service