Fact-checking Mitt Romney's record

Braden GoyetteProPublica
Mitt Romney campaign on Flickr


Editor's Note: This ProPublica article was originally published during the Republican presidential primaries.

The basics:

Former Massachusetts Gov. Mitt Romney is perhaps best known for implementing "RomneyCare," a 2006 health-care law that mandated all Massachusetts residents to have health insurance. FactCheck.org has prepared a primer on the health care law, looking into claims that it has bankrupted the state (it hasn't) and how many Bay Staters actually have health care (a bit over 98 percent).

If you really want to get a sense of what Romney's about, the Boston Globe has an epic 7-part profile charting his development and years as governor. The section on Romney's tenure as the head of the 2002 Olympic planning committee is actually quite interesting, and shows how Romney "tolerated little dissent."

His background:

Romney began his career in business, eventually becoming the CEO of Bain and Co., a private equity firm. A few years later, Romney ran for Senate in 1994 against Ted Kennedy, and lost. After a brief sojourn helping to organize the Winter Olympics, Romney was elected governor of Massachusetts, serving from 2002 to 2006.

If elected, Romney would be America's first Mormon president. The Pew Research Center has a selection of recommended reading on Romney's faith. In 2006, Romney delivered a speech on the role of religion in America, and how he believes his faith would inform his presidency if he were elected. A 2007 New York Times article describes Romney's efforts to appeal to evangelicals.

His record:

On the trail, Romney has emphasized his record creating jobs. But the Los Angeles Times reports that during Romney's time as governor Massachusetts had one of the lowest job creation rates in the country. Bloomberg News also notes that while Bain grew while Romney was CEO, it also cut plenty of jobs.

As governor, Romney took control of the Big Dig, which was already mired in scandal over misspent funds and unsafe design. The Washington Post details how his claims that he would turn the project around never materialized, leaving Boston residents wondering: "If he can't handle [turnpike authority director] Matt Amorello, how is he going to handle Korea or Iran?"

Unlike GOP presidential hopefuls Ron Paul, Michele Bachmann and Rick Perry, Romney was in favor of the stimulus.

Romney has also been criticized for having once held moderate positions on abortion, gun control and gay rights. He describes himself as pro-life, though he said during his 1994 Senate run that "abortion should be safe and legal in this country."

Romney opposed the legalization of gay marriage in Massachusetts, and recently signed a pledge that he will defend the Defense of Marriage Act if elected president.

The American Spectator deemed him a "Rockafeller Republican," and they didn't mean that as a compliment. He has taken a lot of heat from conservatives for criticizing Obama's health care law, while defending the Massachusetts health care legislation he introduced that served as a model for Obama's bill.

Following the money:

The New York Times' ultra-handy tool for comparing the candidates shows that as of early summer, Romney's fundraising was about four-times that of any other Republican. Romney's fundraising paled in comparison to that of another possible competitor, President Obama. (The numbers are a few months old since candidates are only required to file quarterly.)

Open Secrets has a summary of Romney's campaign contributors, and a guide to the Super PACs supporting the different 2012 candidates.

Two campaign finance watchdog groups called for an FEC inquiry after a Romney Super PAC received a mysterious $1 million donation from a company that dissolved shortly afterward. After the calls for an investigation, former Bain Capital executive Edward Conard identified himself as the donor. The Boston Globe has a piece summing up the concerns the episode raises. Romney says that the secrecy of the donation is no longer an issue now that Conard has identified himself.

This report was originally published by ProPublica and is republished here with permission.