Anchorage Daily News

Handel's "Messiah" is Easter music in many parts of the world. In Anchorage, it is traditionally presented before Christmas. The Christmas season begins when Jim Powell sings "Comfort Ye" as he did once again Dec. 7 at West High. It was a spirited "Messiah."

The orchestra was exceptional. It was a joy to watch Concertmaster Nina Bingham and Bryson Andres play with such close sympathy and shared energy. The same can be said of second violins Walter Olivares and Tapaau Fatuleai. The chorus and the vocal soloists all performed creditably, admirably. Then there was Ellen Ruby-Markie singing verses from Luke with a voice that I found thrilling.

Newly refurbished, the West High auditorium sparkled. The acoustics are arguably the best in town. When Maestro Zuehlsdorff lost control of his baton and it flew across the stage, you could hear the little wooden tinkle as it landed among the poinsettias. The expression on Mr. Olivares' face was priceless; finally, something new happens at a performance of the "Messiah."

The only sour note occurred as a smattering of triumphalists in the audience took it upon themselves to sing along with the "Hallelujah" Chorus. No, no, folks. The "Hallelujah" Chorus is for standing, not singing. We stand because, supposedly, the king stood. Mercifully, he did not sing.

There are sing-along "Messiahs" in many cities. If we ever have one in Anchorage, you will be advised in advance, and you will be asked to bring your score so that everyone is singing the same thing. Hallelujah!

-- Diane Pleninger, Anchorage

Did you agree with our latest review? If not (or even if you did), here's an opportunity to respond. "You Be the Critic" is your space to comment on reviews that appear in the Daily News and give your assessment of events that were not reviewed. Post your reviews at You Be the Critic on the blog at adn.com/artsnob, e-mail ubcritic@adn.com or mail your letters to "You Be the Critic," Anchorage Daily News, P.O. Box 149001, Anchorage 99514-9001. Keep letters short, 250 words or fewer, and include your name and phone number for verification. Letters may be republished in any format and become the property of the Daily News.

ADVERTISEMENT