Skip to main Content
Alaska News

Defendant guilty in Bonnie Craig murder

  • Author: Casey Grove
  • Updated: September 29, 2016
  • Published June 15, 2011

It took an Anchorage jury just hours Wednesday to find Kenneth Dion, 41, guilty of raping and killing teenager Bonnie Craig nearly 17 years ago.

The conviction caps an Anchorage murder mystery that began when a hiker found Craig's body Sept. 28, 1994, in McHugh Creek. The subsequent investigation into her death turned cold until 2006, when a DNA sample from Dion linked him to the murder.

During the 21-day trial, Dion's lawyer argued that his client had consensual sex with Craig and that the 18-year-old college student died in an accidental fall.

Prosecutors said Dion bludgeoned the back of Craig's head until she died.

Both sides presented their closing arguments Tuesday in Anchorage Superior Court, each lawyer telling his version of an unsettling chapter in Anchorage history, when posters and bus ads asking "Who Killed Bonnie?" plastered the city.

A jury of nine men and three women delivered the answer Wednesday after less than a day of deliberating: Kenneth Dion.

Several women in the gallery burst into tears when Judge Jack Smith read the verdict at about 4 p.m. before a packed courtroom. A woman standing in the entryway squealed.

Dion, dressed in a black shirt, showed no emotion except for when the judge asked each juror to give his or her verdict out loud. Dion appeared to briefly shake his head while looking toward the jury.

Court officers shackled Dion's hands -- the word "LOST" tattooed across one set of knuckles, "SOUL" inked on the other -- and led him to a holding cell. Judge Smith set Dion's sentencing hearing for Oct. 31.

After the judge and jury left, onlookers cried and hugged each other in the gallery.

"We loved (Bonnie). All the awful things they said, she was nothing but the sweetest kid," Craig's mother, Karen Foster, told reporters outside the courtroom.

Foster was joined by Craig's sister, Samantha Campbell, who said she felt "excellent" following the verdict.

"It was hell sitting through court, seeing pictures of my sister, autopsy photos," Campbell said.

"It's a big sense of relief," said Campbell, who was 12 years old when Craig died and was one of the last people to see her alive.

Upon the discovery of Craig's body at McHugh Creek, south of Anchorage, a massive public effort to find clues ensued. Hundreds of tips poured in. In private, detectives put together a theory. But police found no solid suspects for a dozen years.

That was until New Hampshire authorities contacted Alaska State Troopers. DNA from Dion, who was serving time there for armed robbery, matched semen found inside Craig.

Photos projected in court during the trial showed the back of Craig's head criss-crossed by 11 or 12 lacerations. A blow to the base of the teenager's skull likely killed her, a former medical examiner testified.

State prosecutors Paul Miovas and Jenna Gruenstein walked the jury through Craig's last days alive. They argued that her busy schedule did not include a sexual tryst with Dion, as the defense had claimed.

Miovas explained the apparent lack of blood spatter at the crime scene in closing arguments Tuesday. Dion pushed Craig off the cliff, and she struck a rocky ledge as she fell, the prosecutor said.

As Craig lay wounded in the creek, Dion scrambled down to deliver the final, fatal blows, Miovas had told the jury.

Reach Casey Grove at casey.grove@adn.com or 257-4589.

By CASEY GROVE

casey.grove@adn.com

Local news matters.

Support independent, local journalism in Alaska.

Comments