Skip to main Content
Opinions

We ask Sen. Murkowski to let the Pebble process play out

  • Author: Lisa Reimers
    | Opinion
    , Ventura Samaniego
    | Opinion
    , Brad Angasan
    | Opinion
  • Updated: October 7
  • Published October 7

The village of Ilamna, Alaska is just a small cluster of buildings around crystal-clear Lake Iliamna, a nursery for wild salmon, which at 80 miles long is the largest U.S. freshwater lake outside the Great Lakes. (Bill Roth/Anchorage Daily News)

Perhaps you have seen our ads thanking Sen. Lisa Murkowski for standing up for the permitting process for Pebble. The theme of our ads is “we need jobs” and “we want hope.” While the coastal communities in our region see some benefits from the short commercial fishing season, many in our home communities do not.

Recently, several of our Bristol Bay leaders took to these pages pushing Sen. Murkowski to more be more aggressively involved in the permitting process. We support Sen. Murkowski staying informed and engaged about the Pebble issue. When it comes to the permitting process, we encourage her to help keep it on track. We worry that if Sen. Murkowski inserts herself too far into the Pebble permitting process, it will set a precedent for future resource projects in Alaska. We think we can all agree that Alaska resource development projects engender a fair amount of controversy. This is why we need an objective and transparent permitting process — which is exactly what we have witnessed via the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers for Pebble.

We have all submitted comments to the USACE as part of the permitting process and know that our comments along with all other comments must be fully addressed through the permitting process.

Jason Metrokin, Alannah Hurley, Ralph Anderson and Norm Van Vactor are great, well-intentioned people. However, we want Alaskans to know that they do not speak for our home villages. When we press them for answers and ideas about jobs and hope for our communities, all we hear back are crickets. This is because there are no easy solutions. This is why we continue to press for a full and fair evaluation for the Pebble prospect.

We have seen firsthand what the “no Pebble” scenario looks like for our communities. It is more outmigration. It is more homes split apart as family members move to other places for work. It is higher costs of energy that cripple our communities in the winter. It is watching some of our schools close while others teeter on the fence due to declining enrollment. It lacks hope.

We have long said that development of a mine at Pebble may not be our first choice for an economy for our region, but in the past 20 years it has really been the only choice. We have had longstanding business relationships with the project to provide a range of services for their exploration program. We have brought numerous issues of concern to their attention and have worked with them on realistic solutions. While not perfect, our relationship has produced meaningful jobs for our shareholders. More importantly, it has given us a seat at the table with the potential developer so we can hear firsthand about their plans and have our questions answered.

We agree when Sen. Murkowski says the mine must not have a negative impact on our fisheries. We want her to know we have worked with the Pebble environmental team and their many consultants. We have asked them important questions about their work. We believe the permitting process is the forum to validate whether Pebble can be developed responsibly. And if it can be done right, we are encouraged by what it could mean for our shareholders and communities.

We are hopeful it could bring needed jobs and economic activity to the Iliamna Lake area communities. We are hopeful that it can provide tax revenues for our schools and other languishing infrastructure. We ask that the next time you see stories that the Bristol Bay region opposes development of Pebble, that you will remember us and the views from the communities closest to the proposed project.

Lisa Reimers is CEO of Iliamna Development Corporation. Her residence is split between Anchorage and Iliamna, where she continues to live a traditional lifestyle and manage business.

Ventura Samaniego is CEO of Kijik Corporation. He’s originally from Juneau and has served in several executive leadership capacities for other Native corporations throughout his career.

Brad Angasan is senior vice president of Alaska Peninsula Corporation. Brad is a lifelong commercial fisherman and an advocate for economic opportunity throughout the Bristol Bay region.

The views expressed here are the writer’s and are not necessarily endorsed by the Anchorage Daily News, which welcomes a broad range of viewpoints. To submit a piece for consideration, email commentary(at)adn.com. Send submissions shorter than 200 words to letters@adn.com or click here to submit via any web browser. Read our full guidelines for letters and commentaries here.

Local news matters.

Support independent, local journalism in Alaska.

Comments