We are former attorneys general of the state of Alaska. We served Republican, Democratic and Alaska Independence party governors. We were appointed by Govs. Bill Egan, Bill Sheffield, Steve Cowper, Wally Hickel, Tony Knowles, Sean Parnell and Bill Walker. Our service stretches back more than 50 years.
We support the retention of Justice Susan Carney on the Supreme Court of Alaska. Justice Carney has served the people of this state with distinction and clearly deserves to be retained in office. Her ratings in the Judicial Council poll of all the state’s practicing attorneys are among the highest ever received by any judicial officer. These ratings represent the high quality of her work.
We have read the criticisms of Justice Carney’s work propounded by a group that is opposing her retention. They involve three cases among the several hundred she has decided during her time on the bench, and each criticism grossly misstates what happened in the case:
In John Doe v. Department of Public Safety, the Supreme Court upheld Alaska’s sex offender registration law as constitutional and denied the sex offender’s claim that the law did not apply to him. It also ruled that any offender seeking removal from registration would have to prove, after rehabilitation, that he no longer posed a danger.
In State of Alaska v. Planned Parenthood of the Great Northwest, the Alaska Supreme Court held that a state law that provided full funding for hospital services to a poor pregnant woman who wished to deliver, but denied funding to a poor pregnant woman who desired to end her pregnancy, violated Alaska’s Constitution’s guarantee of equal protection of the law. The Alaska Constitution requires the state to treat people equally who are similarly situated. Here, because two different pregnant women of limited financial means were treated differently by the law, equal protection was violated. The decision of the Alaska Supreme Court simply enforced this important constitutional principle.
In Wielechowski v. State, the Court ruled that, in accordance with the Alaska Constitution, appropriations to the dividend program, like all other appropriations, are subject to the governor’s veto. Contrary to the anti-Carney campaign claims, no member of the Court “ratif(ied) the governor’s decision to (reduce) the PFD." The Court merely determined that the Constitution gave the governor the power to exercise his veto. Because the Legislature did not override it, the veto stood.
Justice Carney’s retention has been unanimously recommended by the Alaska Judicial Council, the citizen agency created by the Alaska Constitution to nominate persons to the governor for appointment to the bench, and tasked by the Legislature to review judicial performance each election year and make recommendations on retention to Alaska’s voters. The Judicial Council has polled all the attorneys in the state as well as court employees, reviewed performance records for all judges, held public hearings and interviewed the judges standing for retention. We agree with the Council’s unanimous recommendation that Justice Carney be retained in her position as Justice of the Alaska Supreme Court.
John Havelock served as Alaska Attorney General from 1970-73; he was appointed by Gov. Bill Egan.
Harold M. Brown served as Alaska Attorney General from 1985-86; he was appointed by Gov. Bill Sheffield.
Douglas B. Baily served as Alaska Attorney General from 1989-90; he was appointed by Gov. Steve Cowper.
Bruce Botelho served as Alaska Attorney General from 1993-2002; he was appointed by Gov. Hickel and reappointed by Gov. Tony Knowles.
John J. Burns served as Alaska Attorney General from 2010-12; he was appointed by Gov. Sean Parnell.
Michael C. Geraghty served as Alaska Attorney General from 2012-14; he was appointed by Gov. Sean Parnell.
Jahna Lindemuth served as Alaska Attorney General from 2016-18; she was appointed by Gov. Bill Walker.
The views expressed here are the writer’s and are not necessarily endorsed by the Anchorage Daily News, which welcomes a broad range of viewpoints. To submit a piece for consideration, email commentary(at)adn.com. Send submissions shorter than 200 words to email@example.com or click here to submit via any web browser. Read our full guidelines for letters and commentaries here.