Alaska trollers suffer unfair king salmon quotas amid strong returns

July 1 is the most anticipated day of the year for Alaska trollers. It marks the start of the summer king season when there are usually lots of salmon to catch and the fishing grounds are fully open. No matter how long they've fished, there is not one troller who doesn't feel the elation of seeing just the right tug on a line that results in a beautiful, shimmering king salmon being hauled over the rail.

That joy is tarnished this year by the fact that Alaska and Canadian trollers are fishing at levels that fall well below sustainable or fair.

The Pacific Salmon Commission has capped Alaska's harvest of king salmon at 237,000 fish, down from 440,000 last year. The troll share is 175,000, a 54 percent reduction from 2014. Fishermen in two Canadian harvest areas have also seen their quotas significantly reduced. The northern troll and sport fleets, who rely heavily on king salmon, are caught in a technical dispute among PSC members over how many king salmon are expected to return to spawn in rivers along the West Coast.

The commission implements the U.S.-Canada Pacific Salmon Treaty, which governs how many king salmon can be caught by Canada and Alaska. Since 1999, a model-based forecasting system has been used to estimate the abundance of fish each year and set harvest quotas in Alaska and Canada. The model used to generate the abundance estimate was developed by U.S. and Canadian scientists on the PSC's Chinook Technical Committee. In recent years, these model estimates have varied widely, creating significant disruption for trollers and their markets.

The Alaska members of the technical committee roundly objected to this year's estimate, which heightens Alaska fishermen's concerns about the accuracy of the abundance-based system and the fact they so often get shortchanged. At this point, we don't know what the proper quota should be, but the Alaska committee members say 237,000 is too low and we are 100 percent behind their efforts to correct the error.

For decades, trollers have paid the price of habitat destruction in the Pacific Northwest. We reduced our harvest and fought to protect and rebuild habitat and keep water in the rivers. We've fended off fish farms in Alaska and advocated wild fish safeguards where they exist. The stocks we've worked so hard to rebuild are now returning to the Pacific Northwest in record numbers, yet Alaska fishermen are being held to a pitifully low quota that fails to recognize that high abundance. Trollers are losing faith they will ever see a fair shake in this process.

During the past two years the Columbia River has experienced supersized runs of king salmon, many of which spend most of their life off the coast of Alaska before returning to the Columbia to spawn. The 2013 and 2014 runs were the largest since 1938, when the first dam was installed on the Columbia. The 2015 forecast predicts the third-largest fall run, and spring and summer Columbia stocks are making a huge showing, causing fishermen to further doubt the validity of the low abundance estimate for Alaska. King salmon are returning to the upper reaches of the Columbia in numbers that far exceed the capacity of available spawning area. Many of these fish are from hatcheries intended to mitigate fishermen for the loss of salmon due to hydropower dams. They are paid for by U.S. citizens, including Alaska fishermen.


In anticipation of the 2014 return, Alaska tried to secure a larger king quota to avoid putting too many fish on the spawning beds, which has been shown to reduce returns of Columbia River king salmon. About 30 percent of Alaska's harvest is typically comprised of these fish and in recent years that percentage has been higher and includes large numbers of hatchery fish. Despite the enormous return, the other U.S. commissioners (from Washington, Oregon, the tribes, and federal government) denied Alaska's request. The fish surplus ended up so large in 2014 that tens of thousands of unspawned hatchery kings were wasted.

Another massive run is predicted for 2015. It's tragic to consider the wanton waste of this highly prized source of food. All our fleet wants is a scientifically defensible number that cares for the resource and provides a fair harvest share. Sadly, some folks to the south would rather destroy these magnificent fish by letting five times the escapement goal return to a drought-stricken river, rather than see one more of them taken by Alaska and Canadian fishermen.

The Pacific Salmon Treaty was signed in 1985 with the goal of rebuilding salmon runs from Oregon to Alaska and distributing the benefits among all West Coast fishermen. At treaty signing, many stocks were significantly depressed. Today, the stocks that migrate to Alaska are considered rebuilt and healthy, yet this year's king salmon quota is nearly 30,000 fish under Alaska's original rebuilding quota of 263,000.

It's unconscionable for the PSC to allow this number to stand. The model underpins the entire chinook agreement and it is seriously malfunctioning to the detriment of Alaska and Canada. Not only is this yet another broken treaty promise, but it puts at risk the health of our industry and regional communities. The Chinook Technical Committee should be put back to work immediately, to right what's wrong here and get a more realistic handle on the quota before the fishing season is over.

The next generation of trollers is just beginning to take the wheel of the fishery. It's an exciting time and there is lots of optimism on the docks, particularly with these big runs of fish. It's just wrong to stifle such hope and enthusiasm with bad science and politics.

Dale Kelley is executive director of the Alaska Trollers Association and has represented trollers in state, federal, and international arenas for 27 years. She says that when not chained to her desk or in a meeting, she feels fortunate to be a deckhand on a troll boat out of a small town in Southeast Alaska.

The views expressed here are the writer's own and are not necessarily endorsed by Alaska Dispatch News, which welcomes a broad range of viewpoints. To submit a piece for consideration, email commentary(at)alaskadispatch.com

Dale Kelley

Dale Kelley has been executive director of the Alaska Trollers Association for nearly 30 years. She serves on the boards of several state and national fisheries organizations and federal advisory groups.