Skip to main Content
Opinions

The Alaska Legislature needs to pass POMV — now

  • Author: Janet McCabe
    | Opinion
  • Updated: April 10
  • Published April 10

It's crunch time in Juneau. Legislators need to pull together and accomplish the essentials!

Next November, most legislative seats plus the governor will be up for election.  That fact underlies much of the thinking in Juneau today, intensifying pressure to finish this session's work and start campaigning.

Legislators are frustrated with their own inability as a group to compromise and reach agreement. Constituents complain — those who rely on the dividend to feed their families or stave off foreclosure, as well as business owners feeling the slowdown of economic recession.

Experts are also weighing in. Oil company representatives have roamed the Capitol describing possibilities for increased petroleum revenues. But timing is a problem, and even significant gains won't take Alaska back to the era when oil funded 80 percent of state government.

The Legislature's own fiscal analyst has estimated that in two years there will be a huge gap between expenditures and revenues, and Alaska's vital "shock-absorber," the Constitutional Budget Reserve, will be drained.

Not acting has a cost of its own. In a recent independent quantification, Mouhcine Guettabi of the UAA Institute of Social and Economic Research concluded that "policy uncertainty is costing the state somewhere between $200 to $600 million (per year) in private capital spending." When the future is uncertain businesses become more conservative.

Seemingly, no one is happy in Juneau, yet this session could end with accomplishments that add certainty and help stabilize the economy! For several years there has been basic agreement between the House and Senate on a structured Percent of Market Value (POMV) system that would pay much of the annual cost of state government from the Permanent Fund Earnings Reserve, and assure ongoing dividends and inflation-proofing. POMV systems are used by most major institutions to protect endowments from market fluctuations.

The House and Senate still disagree about where to set the percentage, and the proportion of the annual draw to be allocated to the dividend. But the numbers are close, and a reasonable compromise could be reached. Enacting POMV is consistent with the 1976 constitutional amendment that established the Alaska Permanent Fund to provide state operating expenses when oil revenues diminished.

The amount of the dividend in the POMV statute must be low enough to avoid jeopardizing future budgets. This suggests an amount approximating the 2018 dividend. Higher dividend levels probably will require additional revenue sources, i.e. broad-based taxes. Alternatively, the continuation of the dividend itself will be threatened.

If, as in the past, the value of the Permanent Fund trends upward, the Earnings Reserve will grow and payouts for state operations and dividends will increase.

I urge the Legislature to pass a POMV statute this session, and to cap this achievement by also passing a proposal to stimulate the economy that was developed by Sheldon Fisher, Alaska's clearheaded and sensible commissioner of Revenue.

His concept, embodied in House Bill 331 and Senate Bill 176, merits full consideration as a way to generate employment in the oil service industry, and pay existing debt without additional cost to the state.

As background, recently the Legislature eliminated the tax credit incentives for new development by small oil companies. They were no longer affordable. But that action left us with previous contractual agreements that must be paid. The state has been repaying these obligations gradually, as allowed by law, but banks will not make loans to the small oil companies based on distant state payments. North Slope and Cook Inlet projects have been shutting down and employment in the oil service sector is declining.

State bonding to make immediate payments on Alaska's existing debt to small oil companies would provide them with cash needed to employ oil service businesses and restart stalled projects. Yet the state's bonding obligation could be paid gradually. The state will negotiate with the companies for a discount to cover interest on the bonds, making the state's cost the same or less than under existing obligations. This is a win-win proposal, putting people back to work in a lagging sector of the economy.

Enacting a statutory POMV system in 2018 is still the primary step toward fiscal stability needed this session, but adding legislation that stimulates the economy, as proposed by Commissioner Fisher, would cap this achievement. With both measures, the 30th Alaska State Legislature could go home with a well-deserved sense of accomplishment.

The memorable statement: "No man's life, liberty or property are safe while the Legislature is in session" was written in 1866 by Gideon John Tucker. Possibly, he was exaggerating!

Janet McCabe and her family have lived in Alaska since 1964. Her education and experience are in community planning with a specialty in population projection.  She is actively involved in several nonprofit organizations, including Alaska Common Ground and Commonwealth North.

Local news matters.

Support independent, local journalism in Alaska.

Comments